Controversial Metal Opinions

[Black Shepherd Carnage]

I can live better with a metaller flat out not liking Megadeth than I can with someone who only likes half of RiP   

[DeadGoon]

Between The Buried and Me are more metal than most bands.

[open face surgery]

That's like saying vaginas are more masculine than most dicks.

[DeadGoon]

That's like saying vaginas are more masculine than most dicks.

Graham Linehan is trying to come to terms with this in a corner somewhere

[Pentagrimes]

Dunno how controversial this is really,but Samhain is Danzig's best band

[Carnage]

I've only heard the one Samhain album (November Coming Fire) and it was shite, so I'd have to disagree. But I prefer the first 3 Danzig albums to any Misfits, dunno if that's controversial or not.

[Don Gately]

Ah lads completely different bands. Misfits are fantastic and Danzigs first 4 imo are also great. Even though perhaps controversially Danzig 1 is the weakest.

[Circlepit]

All Danzig stuff is brilliant. Static Age is a desert island disc for sure.

[hellfire]

While we're on The Misfits, the Michael Graves era is my favourite of theirs.

[The Heretic]

Even though I have every cd, are Tool possibly up their own polyrythm hole with about 3-4 good tunes in reality?

[KingHostile]

Even though I have every cd, are Tool possibly up their own polyrythm hole with about 3-4 good tunes in reality?

YES!

Static age by the misfits rocks, the collections 1 and 2 are desert island discs defo.
First 4 Danzig album are pretty good, Danzig 4 has some brilliant moments and I always liked the darkness of "....how the gods kill", Danzig 2 and 3 are probably the best, the first one does have "Twist of Cain" and "Mother" on it, both heavy on the MTV play list for quite a while.

[jobrok1]

Even though I have every cd, are Tool possibly up their own polyrythm hole with about 3-4 good tunes in reality?

This isn't controversial!
It's just a fact.

[Trev]

Even though I have every cd, are Tool possibly up their own polyrythm hole with about 3-4 good tunes in reality?

I always find a full album of theirs a bit of a slog to get through, but can happily listen to all the individual songs as one offs. Although the stuff I  checked out from the last album sounded pretty indistinguishable from the two before it

[Eoin McLove]

I would agree with that except for Ænima which is a whopper of an album. Maybe you could ditch some of the interludes but I can live with them too.

[Carnage]

I gave Undertow a spin for the first time in years recently, enjoyed it more than ever. The last one was complete dogshit though, and the previous one was no great shakes either. I think they've just bought into their own hype at this stage, throw out any old shite every decade or so, knowing it'll be lapped up.