Controversial Metal Opinions

[Carnage]

There are 5 decent songs on Illud, I have them set up as an EP. The rest are beyond terrible though.

[Eoin McLove]

fdfnjkkhffgbMerbidbhbnnnnnbHAngilvghnnnn

[Mr Barlow]

Blessed Are The Sick for me. First album I got of there's when it was out. Remember picking it up on tape from Our Price on Henry st, went home and listened to it four or five times in a row. One of those albums that connected instantly with me. Just thought it was amazing !

[The Ancient Ones]

Kingdoms Disdained is Morbid's best album since Formulas and beats Domination. There, I said it!

[Pentagrimes]

Immolation are better than Morbid Angel. "Dawn" flattens "Altars" for me.

In fairness I don't think that's an enormously controversial opinion

[Eoin McLove]

'The Bleeding' flattens them all!

Is that controversial enough for you?   

[Pentagrimes]

That's just plain outrageous

Re: Domination- went through a period about 18 months ago of listening to it obsessively and lived it. Put it on the other day for the first time since then and found it weirdly unexciting. Side 2 especially. I find Vincent really fucking irritating on this album particularly. Definitely the point where he started to become the insufferable cunt he is today. The Gene Simmons of death metal.

[Eoin McLove]

I think you'll find it's perfectly rageous 

[Caomhaoin]

'Close to a world below' is the best of Immolation's output. A total beast.

[Anton Arcane]

'The Bleeding' flattens them all!

Is that controversial enough for you?   

Not sure if you're being serious but I actually agree with that statement.

[Eoin McLove]

It's the one I listened to most growing up, followed by 'Covenant' which is my favourite MA album. Immolation are cool but I never listened to them in my formative years.

[Giggles]

I think I remember reading a post on MI about Chuck Schuldiner sneering at some lad on here for wearing an Immolation shirt when he was in Dublin? Or was it a Suffocation shirt? Is that controversial?

[Blackout]

They sound so good here. Heretic type sound sounds so dirty live.

Stricken arise ftw

https://youtu.be/Lk_HLpznSVU

[Paul keohane]

From Gateways through to  Kingdoms Disdained,they've made a bollix of the production.Even on Gateways an album i really like,the fuckin drum sound.I listened to Heretic a while ago,some very good songs on it to be fair!

[Pentagrimes]

I think I remember reading a post on MI about Chuck Schuldiner sneering at some lad on here for wearing an Immolation shirt when he was in Dublin? Or was it a Suffocation shirt? Is that controversial?

Suffocation are largely terrible so I hope it was them.