Timeghouls 2 EPs. The second ep is some of the best death metal ever recorded. 2 songs is enough to  perfectly distinguish a specific style. They never released an album, which is one of the biggest what coulda beens in music.

Vanitas - ceremony, one of those random 1ep band camp bands I heard years ago that never did anything of note since

Grand Belials key - triumph of the hordes, unlike the rest of their material. Sloppy, more traditionally BM & has one of the worst played (but woulnt change it) solos. Objectively terrible music but hard to beat

Blood incantation - interdimensional extinction, great riffs & great artwork & before the hype train got rolling

Personally, best EPs overall:
CELTIC FROST - Morbid Tales AND Emperor's Return
Best Black Metal EP:
CARPATHIAN FOREST -  Through Chasm, Caves and Titan Woods

I've been spinning Gehenna's "First Spell" a lot recently though...


Those two Celtic Frost are excellent alright. Related, I'd also place Apocalyptic Raids pretty high on my list.

Agalloch - Of Stone, Wind and Pillor' is a great EP. The improvement their cover of Kneel to the Cross is on the original. Unbeatable.

Quote from: Caomhaoin on July 11, 2021, 09:01:28 PM
Agalloch - Of Stone, Wind and Pillor' is a great EP. The improvement their cover of Kneel to the Cross is on the original. Unbeatable.

One of the best covers by anyone ever.

Great thread. Cold Dark Place by Mastodon is class.

Quote from: 101_North on July 10, 2021, 07:13:36 PM
An honourable mention for SAP and Jar of Flies. 2 brilliant EP's.

Classics


I'm surprised Bolzer hasn't been mentioned

2 classic EPs
3 even

Good call, Aura is a whopper but Hero just knocked it out of the park. Lese Majesty was great too!

Quote from: Jward on July 12, 2021, 10:57:53 AM
I'm surprised Bolzer hasn't been mentioned

2 classic EPs
3 even

Yes, definitely 3!

Cold Dark Place is a great listen too, really like it a lot.

14 minutes of absolute perfection from Ilenkus, this is up in my favourites of all time, from anywhere


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6P84MF4xSc

Quote from: Mower Liberation Front on July 10, 2021, 07:49:36 PM
But when it comes down to the best ever? 

In Flames - Subterranean.

Amazing ep, and Black Ash Inheritance isn't bad either.

Loads of brilliant eps mentioned already (Haunting the Chapel  :-*), I would add:

Dimension Zero - Penetrations from the Lost World
The Graveyard Dirt eps x 2

Metallica: The $5.98 E.P.: Garage Days Re-Revisited

The original  one with the goofy cover picture (not the re-release). Released right before '..and Justice For All', remember buying it at the time, still got the tape (minus inlay sadly). A solid release but nothing special, not supposed to be . Best track: The Small Hours.


Quote from: Yung Led Zeppelin on July 13, 2021, 12:18:41 PM
14 minutes of absolute perfection from Ilenkus, this is up in my favourites of all time, from anywhere


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6P84MF4xSc

Good call man. And not forgetting that if we were doing a "The best videos" thread, Ilenkus would there again more than merit their place:

https://youtu.be/D5t6zMD0qWI