#525 November 22, 2026, 02:08:08 PM Last Edit: November 22, 2026, 02:10:11 PM by Black Shepherd Carnage
Quote from: Cailleach on November 22, 2026, 01:48:17 PMTo me they come across as a band going through the motions ever since TGW,which afflicts a lot of bands.

To The Nameless Dead could (uncharitably) be considered Primordial's Black album, but making a Black album is necessarily never "going through the motions."

#526 November 22, 2026, 04:07:55 PM Last Edit: November 22, 2026, 08:19:04 PM by jobrok1
Except for the pointless instrumental track, everything on TTND is great. Probably their most consistantly good album almost all the way through.
Easily my favorite of theirs.

Quote from: Black Shepherd Carnage on November 22, 2026, 02:08:08 PM
Quote from: Cailleach on November 22, 2026, 01:48:17 PMTo me they come across as a band going through the motions ever since TGW,which afflicts a lot of bands.

To The Nameless Dead could (uncharitably) be considered Primordial's Black album, but making a Black album is necessarily never "going through the motions."

It's a band treading water to my ears. Aside from Exile, everything after TGW, bar a few songs here and there, doesn't appeal to me

More or less the same as that except Exile didn't grab me and I have a soft spot for Where Greater Men Have Fallen but probably down to playing gigs with them around that.

I totally understand people who don't like TTND, but in the sense that it was a departure from everything they'd done before it, it's not treading water either.

Fair point. Was into it at the time as well but no interest since.

Quote from: Black Shepherd Carnage on November 22, 2026, 04:52:30 PMI totally understand people who don't like TTND, but in the sense that it was a departure from everything they'd done before it, it's not treading water either.

That's a reasonable point.

I commend them for trying something different, but it's just not an album i have any real desire to listen to these days.

#532 November 22, 2026, 08:12:56 PM Last Edit: November 22, 2026, 08:26:42 PM by Nazgûl
I think whether it's subconscious or intentional, lots of bands will naturally write for big stages/festivals as they become bigger. With Primordial it seemed like it was very intentional after the success of TTND. The gaps between albums went from 2 years to 4 from then on also. Likely due to extra touring I'd imagine (and just getting older and having other commitments perhaps). But, but my logic there -- you'd imagine the songs on the last album would have been the opposite after a long period of lockdown and no shows.

'Exile' is easily their best full length anyway since TTND. The other albums combined probably have one solid full length between them...songs like Seed of Tyrants and those weirder ones, plus two or three of the anthemic ones

One song I've been spinning a fair bit though in more recent times is God's Old Snake. I wish there were others since that had those class death metal vocals. A pure one off, oddly enough.

Quote from: Nazgûl on November 22, 2026, 08:12:56 PMI think whether it's subconscious or intentional, lots of bands will naturally write for big stages/festivals as they become bigger. With Primordial it seemed like it was very intentional after the success of TTND. The gaps between albums went from 2 years to 4 from then on also. Likely due to extra touring I'd imagine (and just getting older and having other commitments perhaps)

I was going to make basically the same point. You listen to Alan's podcast and it's clear playing live is the main attraction for him, and these days that means the festival circuit. Does that impact the recording process and the need for one or two big stage banger songs? He would disagree am sure but seems obvious from WGMHF onwards.

Also love Exiles. Its their version of Killers - it will never be seen as their best but it sounds great all the way through and even the minor songs on it like Sunken Lungs I enjoy. Its a fun record by their standards.