Quote from: astfgyl on July 07, 2026, 05:14:26 PM
Most definitely.
Lots of great shouts in this thread. Will have to agree on the mentions of Thou (super heavy live as well), 4th of July (which Thou also covered, lol) and Slayer's Hell Awaits. I recently revisited Slayer generally after a while of not listening and teenage me was on the ball, they're heavy as fuck.
What's heavy is always a great question because it'll cover so much ground and so many people have a different idea of what it means for them. I'll always lean towards the sludge end of it though because that's really where it hits in my mind, "heavy" and "fast" need a hell of a lot of other things working to bring them perfectly together (see Full of Hell, Slayer, etc). There has to be some "hang back" in the flow of the riff to really evoke that feeling. It's what drew me into heavy music properly and is to this day, my favourite kind to seek out.
I'm kind of surprised no one has mentioned this classic though (maybe too obvious?), because if I had to distill it to one answer to the question it's probably this. Just dripping with hate and claustrophobic in its sound/feel, it's the performance, production, the whole package.
Another big one at the moment for me would be Primitive Man. The word crushing is thrown about fairly liberally, but they really do just that, and it's very overwhelming live. Saw a comment on some video that said "Ethan McCarthy sounds like a dinosaur", and that's really the gist of it
This is in the buildup to the hit and like, it's in the fucking title, lol
ochoill mentioned Inter Arma, and I'd actually pick another track off that album, again with that dragging feel where the snare hangs back ever so slightly from around 3:53 on, then back on it for the chorus, just perfect, and the effect gets more extreme later in the song
Shout out to our very own Slomatics and Nomadic Rituals as well, who frequently dish out the exact kind of stuff that comes to mind when I think of this


. What I think doesn't matter anyway in the grand scheme of things, tis just my experience of them.